My philosophy for training and teaching has developed over the last twenty or so years of training and teaching martial arts. I have written about facets of my philosophy here and there over the years, and now I would like to bring it together and attempt to write a draft of what I think my philosophy might be.
- What is HEMA to me?
- Quality of discussion
- Training safely and effectively
- Safety and responsibility
- Learning to do sparring well
- The role of tournaments
- Training a system
- Writing books and articles
- Offering professional instruction
What is HEMA to me?
I think that practising HEMA is one of the most wonderful things I can do with my time. HEMA has so much value in the modern world. I hope I can help my students become better fencers and also better people, and I hope that my legacy of this approach continues and is passed down when my advanced students move on to found their own clubs.
When I think about what HEMA is for me, I have a very particular point of view. It needs to be historically verifiable (the ‘H’), it needs to be European in nature (the ‘E’, although this can be a bit fuzzy at the edges!), and it needs to be a realistic and competent martial art (the ‘MA’). If what we are doing is lacking in any of these areas, it is no longer HEMA in my mind. It can still be a beneficial practice, and it can still be a lot of fun, but I wouldn’t consider it HEMA unless it satisfies these three points.
I see the difference between historical fencing, classical fencing, and modern fencing to be largely down to mindset and recreation vs creation. To this end, it doesn’t really matter to me how old a system is when considering if it can be HEMA; for it to be HEMA in my mind, the mindset and practice has to be one of recreation rather than modifying and creating something new.
I believe that honesty is important in martial arts. When we are honest with ourselves, we can ask ourselves important questions, such as whether we are training what is actually written in our sources, or instead just training with a particular kind of weapon? For example, am I training the system of Polish sabre, or simply training WITH a Polish sabre? Another important question for analysing your practice honestly is if your art is really “a killing art”, or are there more non-lethal facets to consider and maybe even embrace?
For me, teaching and writing about HEMA has become my profession. I think it is quite possible to turn hobbies into paid work, although one must be careful to set it up in a healthy fashion so that you can still enjoy your work.
Quality of discussion
Discussion, argumentation, learning; these are all things that participation in HEMA can bring to enrich our lives. I really appreciate a good argument which leads to growth on both sides of the debate. However, people (myself included) need to learn how to argue well before the debates can be useful. Learning to observe details is also a very important skill to develop.
Memes annoy me. A little silliness in a serious pursuit can be fun, but being bombarded by nonsense for most of the day whenever I look online is not even remotely helpful. I know it is a naive thought, but I’d like memes that perpetuate myths to die out so that the myths and misconceptions can also die out – the mistranslated “end him rightly” meme is a prime candidate for this. Similarly, “pithy” statements such as stick the pointy end in the other guy are quite unhelpful and contribute very little of use to discussions.
That being said, being able to encapsulate an important detail in an enduring soundbite can really help your message spread.
Training safely and effectively
Although it might be fun NOW to win more bouts, I want to make sure that I can keep training until I’m in my 80s (or even older). Therefore, I have to ensure that I am training for the future, and not accepting short-term gains in exchange for my long-term health. I can consider my body structure like a plumbing system, and must pay attention to the warning signs of pain and learn the difference between the pain from a solid hit and the pain that tells me a muscle or joint is being overworked and needs a rest. Sometimes, it is valuable to know when not to win a fight.
We need to learn how to make both our footwork and handwork effective, so that they can work independently yet still support each other. We need to make sure that our footwork lessons are functional and effective, otherwise they are a waste of our time. One of the best ways we can train footwork is to play games like children. We can make footwork part of other exercises that are commonly practised in a more static fashion, such as Meyer’s four openings drill.
Training isn’t only for the salle. I can do things to keep fit while working from home, to keep developing my strength, and to make sure that I don’t damage myself by sitting for too long every day. Paying attention to our health is important, and therefore I take warm-ups seriously in my club. Furthermore, I can spend my time constructively at home or while travelling, by reading the original sources, and thinking about how to parse, understand, and interpret their instructions.
I think there are many similarities between fencing and driving, and it is interesting to compare the different activities we do to see what the similarities and differences are, and what we can learn from the other things that we do in life.
Learning to train in a consistent fashion is of incredible importance, not only to ourselves, but for the benefit of our training partners. We have to be able to give the correct stimulus in drills, otherwise our training partner cannot practise the correct response, and the drill breaks down. An excellent example of this is with the Schaitelhaw and how we fence from Alber. Learning to do things correctly, every time, is imperative.
One of the best ways to do this is to start by learning big motions before trying to condense them and make them smaller and tighter. A good example of this is learning the position of Vom Tag over the head before working with the sword at the shoulder. Thereafter, once we learn to make the motions properly and in line with the tactical advice of our chosen system, we can look at ways to incorporate variations into our practice, such as the position of Vom Tag on the left shoulder.
It’s also immensely important to give yourself the opportunity to have your performance judged by strictly boolean data, that you cannot hide from or excuse away. Test cutting is an excellent way to challenge yourself if you believe that you are a good fencer but find that you cannot cut through even the softest and easiest target with a sharp sword; but like any other exercise, we have to learn the basics first and then make sure the exercises give us proper skill development in test cutting.
Safety and responsibility
No matter how much protective equipment we wear, or how flexible our swords are, there is always the chance that something will go wrong and an accident will occur. I believe that we all have a responsibility to our training partners, and that it is our own personal responsibility to look after those with whom we train. We must develop a healthy control of our actions, whatever it is that we attempt to do.
People often talk about the difference between sparring with steel swords and sparring with synthetic swords. I think this is a red herring, and what is more important is to talk about intensity during training, as this makes more difference to risk and safety than using steel or synthetic training tools.
However, our training tools do need to be suitable safe. A safe training sword should be suitable for the discipline in question, and should have some kind of tipping solution, suitable flexibility in the thrust, and (for simple-hilted swords) an appropriate schilt or ricasso beside the crossguard.
Learning to do sparring well
When I spar, I need to learn how to deal with whatever the opponent throws at me, regardless of how well-formed or “correct” I think it is. If I can’t deal with it, I get hit, and that’s my problem. Therefore, I think it is important to include things like attacking the hands in sparring, so I that I can learn to keep myself safe.
I believe that physical characteristic and personal attributes, such as height and reach or speed and athleticism, is a poor strategy in the beginning. Relying on attribute fencing can bring medals in the short-term but leads to plateau in the long-term; a better approach is to learn to fence properly without having to rely on your attributes, and then, once you are a skilful fencer with a strong grasp of your system, you can then begin to personalise how you use your system according to your physical (and mental) attributes.
In my experience, sparring is not always the best training method to become better at sparring. Instead, we should drill intelligently, increasing the complexity of our exercises until simple lessons become almost like sparring, so that the fundamental skills and body structures become ingrained enough that we may apply difficult techniques in sparring. Being able to maintain and display good technique is very important, even when under pressure!
As a shorter person, I often find myself sparring with taller opponents. There are all kinds of myths about the short person, how to win against a taller opponent, or even that victory as a short person is impossible; it is important to recognise these myths for what they are (nonsense), and to know that the “secret” to success as a shorter person is simply to do everything properly and correctly, all the time, with no shortcuts.
I think that the afterblow is one of the most important training tools that we can use when learning to fence safely, and we should train the withdrawal assiduously, to avoid being hit.
The role of tournaments
What we have seen in longsword tournaments over the last decade or so is that there has been a distinct improvement in people’s skill, and this can be attributed at least somewhat to the amount of time people spend making sure their techniques can work under pressure. We have seen the development of more historical technical in modern tournaments as more and more fencers increase in skill and as the average, baseline skill becomes higher in any given tournament.
We cannot allow the tournament scene to stagnate, because then it will cease to be as helpful, and will then branch away from the study of the sources, as it becomes a game with its own techniques and conventions. There are several thing we can do as a community to safeguard the future of HEMA tournaments so that they remain useful to the community for years or decades to come.
We can never simulate a “real fight” with our tournaments, and so it is simply not worth trying. Instead, we should pick a goal that is realistically achievable, choose a fencing behaviour that we would like to encourage and to see develop, and model our tournaments and rules on accomplishing that. This also helps to position tournaments as a training tool, rather than than making them the end goal of all of our training.
Furthermore, we shouldn’t think of our equipment in terms of whether or not it is “tournament legal”, but in terms of how useful and reliable it is in general. Phrasing everything in terms of tournaments puts a certain spin on our discussions and thinking, and learning to phrase things more generally and inclusively can be beneficial.
Training a system
I try to follow a source (or group of related sources) as best I can. This means prioritising the actions and concepts from those sources; if they don’t work, then I need to diagnose my problem and learn what I need to do in order to improve my skills to make them work. It means examining my practice with regard to the sources, and cutting out actions that the sources don’t seem to describe – for example, Ringeck doesn’t discuss very many feints, so when fighting according to that system, I should try to work more directly toward my opponent.
In the beginning, I believe we should focus on learning about the system we study, rather than merely learning tricks. However, tricks are a part of many systems, and so we should not hesitate to add the tricks once we have a solid grasp of the system. We can follow this same approach with systems and tricks or “hacks” in everyday life as well.
We can never learn a historical system simply by picking up swords and “seeing what works”. In my opinion, we absolutely must have historical source material for us to make an honest claim that we are studying a historical fighting system such as Viking sword and shield, otherwise we are being slightly dishonest with ourselves as to the validity and accuracy of what we are doing.
There is always the question about how valid it is to question the masters, and when can we pronounce that one of the source is flawed? I think we have to become skilful and knowledgeable fencers first, otherwise our opinions are merely that: opinions. Another similar question is why not fight with mixed weapons more often? Again, I think we need to become skilful and knowledge fencers first, otherwise our experiments are not very useful; they might be fun, but if we gain results from an early experiment, before we can conduct the experiment more correctly and more usefully, might colour our thoughts and impressions unhelpfully for quite some time afterwards.
Writing books and articles
I write books that I publish through Fallen Rook Publishing, a publishing company that I set up in 2013 and that has now published 20 or more titles from a variety of different authors. It is important to write books, I believe, because this is a valuable way to spread information and ideas throughout the community, with greater permanence than making a YouTube video or a Facebook post. People in the HEMA community seem to place value on good information, which makes it worth taking the time to write and publish.
I find that writing articles to post to my blog on this website helps me to clarify my thoughts about different issues. It lets me answer common questions that I see occurring again and again in the community, and to provide resources for beginners and for more advanced practitioners.
I don’t believe in just “producing content”, because I hate the word “content”. I don’t “consume media” and I would be upset if people “consumed” my work; I much prefer to “read and understand” what other people write about, I prefer to “write intelligent and thought provoking pieces” for others to read and consider, and I prefer when other people take the time to read my words, think about them, and then engage in meaningful discussion or debate without resorting to pithy one-liners or memes.
You can buy my books from the Fallen Rook Publishing online shop, or through the online shop attached to this very website that you are currently reading. I usually take books with me for sale at the various events that I attend, or you can always just contact me to ask about acquiring something.
Whenever you buy one of my books, I don’t get a lot of money from each sale, but it does mount up and the income lets me spend time writing and teaching and making my ideas available to the community. I appreciate any and all support that you are willing to offer, including donations towards my coffee fund!
Offering professional instruction
I make my living by teaching HEMA and by other HEMA-related activities, such as writing and publishing books. As a result, I spend a lot of time travelling and teaching, and I also study different teaching models and methodologies. I try to run a “good HEMA club”, learning from all the lessons in my experience, and also try to help other club leaders understand how to face these same issues. Furthermore, I try to help people learn more about the important skills that are critical to being a good training partner, and try to make sure to address these skills explicitly in almost every lesson I teach.
I believe that the instructor will often make or break anyone’s interest and success with studying a martial art. Therefore, I try to give my very best when teaching, and I endeavour to make it both fun and helpful.
If you would like to hire me to teach at your event, then I guarantee to bring you top-class professional instruction, and I will also be there and make myself available for your event participants to come and talk to me about ideas, training, interpretations, or whatever currently intrigues them.
Alternatively, if you would like to visit me in Liverpool for a residential training course, then I can put you up and give you my undivided attention for your stay. We can study whatever takes your interest, and work to improve your skills and knowledge in a deep and lasting fashion.
If you would like to support my writing efforts, please consider donating a little something towards my coffee fund!